Saturday, Jul 23, 2011 at 09:09
I agree mate all new TD engines are very reliant on good quality diesel. And yes I have preference for Toyota for reasons of personal experience. I use Nissan's also and they have many design points that are better than Toyota which can be quite bland (and bloody expensive for what you get).
We currently have 9 vehicles in our fleet, these are all replaced every 70,000k. Currently we have 6 Nissan Patrol 3.0l TD cab chassis fitted with Obieco (Telstra type) Pods, and 2 Toyota work mate V8 TD cab chassis fitted with the same Pods. Apart from the obvious power advantage the Toyota's are just much more reliable in the off road conditions we use them in. I have herd of all horror stories about the V8 and the alternator etc getting wet and packing it when repatedly being exposed to river crossings but none of these issues have occurred to us.
The Nissan's on the other hand all have to have their clutch replaced before the 700000k mark, they have always let us down with a clutch failure in off road difficult conditions (Sand, boggy ares atc) Nissan acknowledges to us that the clutch is designed as a fuse to protect the engine and drive line and that they are an issue when used in difficult off road conditions, and they don't give us warranty for them (one failed at 23,000k) Also when the clutches fail they damage the fly wheel which must be replaced and cost us about 3k for clutch and fly wheel replacement. (We now factor this expense into their running costs) (and yes all of our drivers are experienced 4x4 drivers who have done many courses and have 10+ years of ecperience or more)
We have just purchased 2 brand new patrols and one of those has had the spigot bearing fail in the bush, causing the the gear box to seize (get stuck in gear) this required a flat bed tow 400k to the nearest dealer (This vehicle has done 4000km). When Nissan looked at it they acknowledged that they had a number of these fail and may consider a recall (we have a second vehicle of similar age and KM's).
The Toyota's have required nothing other than routine service and maintenance.
I acknowledge that the Nissan's are a more comfortable vehicle, have nicer features and ride better, but the Toyota's, stop and tow better and don't have the reliability issues.
This is from my personal experience and why I tend to favour Toyota products when spending my own money.
Vehicle number 9 in the fleet is a Nissan X-trail TD and it is a fantastic little vehicle that punches way above its weight for towing ability and comfort.
Regards
Jas
FollowupID:
734376