Tuesday, Mar 06, 2007 at 11:35
Birdy,
I think Darian is spot on, when you travel it is amazing to see that people can travel and be happy in just about anything.
I will take issue with your comparison between set up times in a tent vs a camper trailer. Depends on the camper type, but you can set up a camper trailer much quicker than a tent, and by set up I don't just mean throw the tent out, but set up ready for dinner, a beer and a relax. We travelled in a KK for six months and spent quite a bit of that time with family members who brought tents (including an Oz Tent). We were always relaxing and ready to go
well before them. Hard floors are obviously better in this regard than soft floors. That said, I really like the Oz Tents.
I always find it interesting that people tend to focus on set up/pack up times as being how long it takes to physically fold your tent/camper. The difference is, in my opinion, measured in a few minutes. The real time to pack up/set up is the time taken to pack all the crap away ready to fold up. This time is significantly increased when you travel with kids and the attendant, bikes, clothes, shoes, sports gear, toys, etc......, etc. In this regard I think that how your gear is organised and accessed becomes more important than how long it takes to physically pack fold your tent/trailer/caravan. This, I believe, is what gives a decent camper or a caravan the advantage because you can invariably organise your gear better.
Roadside stops for lunch or a cuppa? Yeah, the caravan is the way to go, but again a decent camper trailer will serve you pretty
well and are often just as quick. Can't sit inside though unless you bother to set it up.
Aircon would be nice, but it is stating the obvious that you need 240v to run it. This ties you to van parks (in which case you might as
well get a decent van) or a generator. Just my personal opinion, but if aircon is a major factor in your decision, you are kind of missing the point of travelling around this country. As someone else suggested, over 12 months you should be able to plan your trip to avoid the worst of the heat.
Im.away was right in suggesting that you ask yourself where you want to go and set up accordingly. A van will seriously limit you (unless you are prepared to leave it and take the tent for short trips), a camper trailer somewhat (but really only the very serious stuff that you may not consider with a 1-2 year old anyway) and a tent/rooftop tent not at all. When you do travel you will pick up heaps of info on great spots from other travellers, and will no doubt change your plans accordingly. That is a great thing, but you will be disappointed if you hear of somewhere you would like to go and find you can't because of your chosen setup. My advice, plan for some decent 4WD stuff.
Again, there is some confusion I think (probably caused by marketeers trying to get their product into a lucrative market) about what constitutes an off road trailer/van. I'd warrant that I could get most caravans available on the market along the
Gibb River Road,
Mitchell Falls, etc. But what kind of condition will it be in at the end and for how long could you do it before a catastrophic failure? To me, 'off road' is not so much about getting over a tricky, rocky, twisty short section, but doing thousands of kilometres on corrugated/rough dirt roads without significant failure. Here I think most caravans (off road or not) are at a distinct disadvantage to a decent off road camper. Tents are not an issue at all of course.
Lastly you mention coughing up some creature comforts by going from a van or camper to a tent. More than you might think. A week or two away is one thing, but the 12 months you propose is an entirely different kettle of fish and some of those small inconveniences can magnify over that sort of time frame. Still, as Darian pointed out people can, and do, travel with some amazingly simple set ups and still have the time of their life.
I'm obviously camper biased, but good luck with the decision and hope you have a great time.
Matt.
AnswerID:
225592
Follow Up By: Member - Brian H (QLD) - Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 00:25
Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 00:25
Well on my Cape trip I tented it and the others had camper trailers and the set up times were about the same, with many times I was sitting having a beer watching them finish setting up.
It just depends on your set up as to how long it takes and my set up is very basic so is very quick to say the least.
Oh course if i'm staying more that a couple of nights and want to set up tarps etc then it will take me a lot longer thats for sure and also to pack up.
Either way ...... its great to get out and just do it :).
Brian
FollowupID:
486641
Follow Up By: Birdy - Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 13:51
Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 13:51
Matt,
I hear what you are saying and to be honest I agree. If I had my way all our travel would be to secluded and remote areas accessed only by 4wd. We love camping and 4wdriving and I really dont like the idea of taking a caravan. Had my heart set on a Off Road camper similar to the KK with a dinghy etc. The one thing affecting our accomodation is our 1 year old baby. I need to consider our baby before ourselves and being in a camper or tent, we are bound to get some days of extreme heat no matter how much we try and avoid it.
Aircon - Dont think we are missing the point of travelling around Oz at all. Once again this is purely for the baby not ourselves. My wife and I are happy 'roughing it ' but as the baby is so
young its not that easy. We really only have this window of opportunity in the next 10+ years to do this trip and if we dont go now we may not be able to until we are old and
grey.
All in all we dont like cities and love both the beauty and solitude of the bush/beach and getting away from it all. If there is a way that I can take a full off road camper trailer then we definately will, as long as our baby doesnt have to suffer in any way.
The main reason of this post was to see how others may have travelled with very
young children. Up until this post we hadnt even considered a caravan yet like all methods of travel/accomodation there are pro's and cons.
We appreciate your reply and agree with what you have said, ultimately we are looking at the best scenario possible to make our trip as enjoyable as yours sounds like it was. Something will need to be sacrificed somewhere .......
Cheers
Birdy
FollowupID:
486707
Follow Up By: Member - Matt M (ACT) - Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 14:27
Wednesday, Mar 07, 2007 at 14:27
Whatever way you choose to go, it will be a unique experience. Make the most of it.
Cheers,
Matt.
FollowupID:
486716