Tuesday, Oct 10, 2006 at 10:10
If the outlet is protected by a 16A breaker then the cable supplying the outlet will be able to carry 16A (plus) so plugging a 15A load into it will be OK. Now if you are concerned about the diversity factor in relation to other loads on the circuit then that would apply in the case of any installation which has multiple outlets on a single spur. This is exactly the situation the UK Ring Main system was developed to overcome and is one of the reasons, in my opinion, why it is the best and most safe domestic electrical system in the world. Note: we run light flex to many appliances in Oz (video players, TVs, table lamps, electric blankets etc) which is only rated for (say) 5A yet it's backed up by a 16A breaker or (even worse) a rewireable fuse! Is that crazy or what?
Certainly a kettle will draw 10A but only for a short time, a toaster is probably another 5A but again only for a short time. If you look at the tripping characteristics of an MCB (Miniature Circuit Breaker) you'll note that they will withstand a low level overload for a fairly long time - I can't recall offhand but probably long enough to make your coffee and do your toast. If it won't withstand it for that period then the breaker will trip and you'll learn to wait until the kettle is boiled before you do your toast. This is no different to the situation you would face in a van park if your wife used her 1800W hairdryer while you’re boiling the kettle (forget the toast!), it would be too much for the 15A supply and may trip the breaker – problem?
The point is that the _risk_ of this practice creating a fire or causing electrocution is miniscule, at worse it will trigger the protection devices into doing what they are designed for.
Nevertheless, you are correct to in highlighting these issues and I’ll repeat that my formal advice is for people to have the installation done correctly but it should be understood that basic electricity is not a Mystical Black Art which only “The Chosen Few” of the electricians union understand. In most countries it’s perfectly legal for people to do their own electrical work and the world is not full of burned houses filled with electrocuted bodies. Mind you I have seen some pretty bad work :) then again I’ve seen some electricians who didn’t know their SWA from their mineral insulated.
>There is a reason why things are done the way they are.
Emmmm… I know, I’ve been involved with the Standards bodies in this area on more than one occasion.
Mike Harding
PS. Interesting point Kiwi about whether we should have an earth system at all!? Certainly I consider earthing my generator in the bush would make things more dangerous.
mike_harding@fastmail.fm
FollowupID:
457201