Tuesday, Apr 18, 2006 at 13:56
Hi folks
Gosh, where do I start? I don't want to take up this
forum discussing medical issues that are not it's purpose but I do want to reply as briefly as I can to some of the comments that have been made. I only mentioned my son's medical condition to emphasize that the information I was seeking was important. As Phil said, I was not seeking advice or a debate about epilepsy.
Firstly, I want to thank Phil, Gramps, Bonz, Porl and Taize (the latter two's comments are in the next links) for coming to my defence in asking Qlddisco to respect our decision and to not assume we are being irresponsible in relation to our son's health needs. Thank a lot everyone.
I also want to clear up that Qlddisco and I do not know each other at all and also that we are not doctors.
Qlddisco, thanks for your concern about our son's wellbeing. I understand you think that we are being reckless and putting him at risk by taking him on this trip and perhaps feel that we are putting our desire for this trip before his health needs. You are obviously trying to come to his defence and help him as far as you can. From your own experiences you know how serious epilepsy can be and the thought of a child having a serious seizure, lying unconscious in the outback a long way from an ambulance or hospital no doubt fuels your concern and anger. I too would be equally concerned if I thought a parent was putting their child at such a risk. Nothing on earth would make me put my child at such a risk and his health is primary and, of course, more important than any trip.
My son does not have tonic clonic seizures (previously referred to as grand mal seizures). He has juvenile absence seizures. As you know from your experiences with your wife absence seizures do not involve falling to the gound or a lack of oxygen or shaking. He simply loses consciousness for roughly 8 seconds whilst still standing. Because he doesn't fall (thus doesn't hurt himself) and doesn't have any loss of oxygen he never needs an ambulance or hospitalization.
After thorough research we have decided not to medicate our son with tthe usual anti-epilepsy medication because of thier known and unknown short and lon-term toxic effects. Instead we have chosen to 'treat' his epilepsy with the ketogenic diet. As you may know this is recognised as a viable medical alternative to drugs for treating epilepsy. It is receiving lots of attention lately in the scientific literature and more and more paediatric neurologists are seeing it as a sometimes remarkably successful treatment for this condition. We personally know and have spoken with others who have had complete and long-term cessation of their seizures using this diet.
As you may have experienced yourself, whilst we are not doctors, when parents (and in your case sibling and husband) have loved ones with a serious medical condition they can become very informed about the relevant subject. A dietitian at a large
Sydney hospital who treats children with epilepsy with this diet told me recently that I knew more about the diet than she did and was asking me for information. I mention this not to brag but as an example to show that whilst not being a doctor I am not uninformed.
Since our son started this diet 5 weeks ago he has had markedly less seizures and I hope and expect (from others' experiences and my own research) that this will continue and, indeed, improve.
Qlddisco, thanks for trying to help. Sometimes too many people turn a blind eye when they see kids treated badly and they should speak out. Kids are so powerless and at the mercy of their parent's. Better to speak out needlessly than not at all. I hope this alleviates your concerns somewhat.
Cheers
Anne
FollowupID:
422759