Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 17:14
G'day Austravel,
Okay; where do I start??? hahaha
The first thing I'd like to say is that
mine (and yours by the sound of it), has never actually over-heated (ie: never got to the point where it has boiled and caused me to stop and fix something).
However, it has got right up to almost being in the RED zone at times. The things I've already done (and which were probably a waste of time/money in retrospect) are:
1. New PWR double-sized radiator with free-flowing tubes (so they say)
2. New fan hub
3. New thermostat
4. Cut hole in bonnet and put scoop above turbo
5. Fitted new turbo recently (I thought this MAY have reduced heat a bit as the OE turbo is water-cooled and the new Schwitzer is not), but that wasn't the primary reason for upgrading.
6. Tried removing Lightforce 240s and putting them on top of the bullbar
7. Tried driving with the plastic air-
dam underneath the radiator removed
8. Tried various types of anti-freeze/boil stuff
9. Stuck 2 bottles of chit in the radiator that are supposed to seal up any tiny cracks in the head if there are any (can't remember the name of it, but I got it from Repco and it was recommended by somebody on here).
10. Have fitted a VDO water temp gauge with sender unit mounted in top radiator hose
11. Have fitted a EGT gauge to see if there is any relationship between exhaust temps and water temps (there really is no relationship apart from if the engine is running for prolonged periods at high speed....anything over about 105k/h, both temps do go up).
12. New radiator cap
13. New radiator hoses
14. Added a 10" Davies Craig fan in front of air-cond condenser which I can manually turn on....maybe I should upgarde this to a 12" or 14" jobbie?
The only thing that I haven't done yet, and which someone on here suggested I should do (can't remember who it was, but he was a bit smug about how he did things;-)) is to change the impeller in the water pump. The bloke who talked about it said he could fix my problems really easy by fitting a new impeller which would stop cavitation of the water. He would not elaborate, even though a few of us asked him for more info :-((.
I've also thought that maybe I might take the winch off this summer as
well as the
driving lights and see if the extra air flow assists.
We have had a few quite warm days lately, but I haven't had to go too far and not with the camper on anyway.
One thing to keep in mind is that when the Nissan's gauge goes up to around the 3/4 mark, your truck is not over-heating at that point. According to my VDO gauge, the temp in the top hose at that time is around 110oC and it seems as though the concensous of opinion is that up to about 120oC is okay when say, going up a
hill....but you wouldn't want to see it up at 120oC all day. I haven't yet gotten the VDO gauge to go to 120oC and so I try not to worry too much. I rely more on the VDO gauge these days (even though the Nissan gauge is still functional). I also tend to drive and change gears according to the EGT gauge as much as anything else.
It has been said on this
forum before that the 4.2 motor does not have anywhere near the size water galleries that the Toyota 4.2 motor has. As such, you have this huge mass of motor that has smallish "veins" running through it trying to collect the heat and take it through to the radiator for cooling purposes.
Another thought which I've had recently is to instal another temp sender unit in the intake where the water from the bottom radiator hose is about to re-enter the motor. Having changed turbos, I now have a "blank" bolt where the banjo bolt used to be that had water going to or from the old turbo. I could take this plug out and have it drilled and tapped to take a VDO sender, which I could then take to my gauge via a switch. That way I could switch between top and bottom radiator hoses and see how much cooling the radiator is actually achieving. This is the same thing I have done with my EGT gauge; have a thermocouple above and below the turbo so I can swap between pre-turbo and post-turbo EGTs.
I don't suppose this helps you, other than to say that you don't really have to worry too much as long as your Nissan gauge isn't going too far past 3/4 of the way.
Cheers
Roachie
AnswerID:
143501
Follow Up By: Austravel - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:01
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:01
Aaaah just as I thought, you've tried everything and know all the pit falls. Much the same as I tend to do, more to try and solve the problem than anything else.
Is the VDO sensor you have right in the hose?? I notice I have a bung in the thermostat housing so maybe could use this.
On the flat
mine gets to 3/4 no dramas. However on long gradual climbs or steep climbs
mine sits right on the line between "HOT" and the red. So in hilly country it's close to the hot line for quite some time. Is this the same as you?????
FollowupID:
396999
Follow Up By: Member - Roachie (SA) - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:11
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:11
Yeh, if I'm trying to maintain a decent speed it does tend to get above half way even on the flat and hotter still if I attack a
hill and try to keep the speed up. I have found that backing off and doing say 90k/h is the best answer.
The VDO sender unit is mounted in a bung that is welded to a length of stainless steel pipe (about 5" long) that I have inserted into the top radiator hose.....I cut about 1.5" out of the hose just where that support is (which I've removed) that is/was attached to the power steering bracket. I thought of using that spare brass bung near the thermostat, but couldn't be bothered drilling and tapping it (the thread is a different size to the VDO sender unit.)
Cheers mate
Roachie
FollowupID:
397001
Follow Up By: Austravel - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:25
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:25
Thanks Roachie, I do appreciate the info and advice.
When you say it goes above 1/2 when pushing it is that with the camper on or without??
With out the camper I have no problem at all. With the camper and trying to maintain a speed or the slow steep climb then it's all over red rover.
FollowupID:
397004
Follow Up By: Member - 'Lucy' - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:33
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:33
Listen hear you!
Your name is being changed from Roachie to 'blow fly' (greatest pest known to man kind).
Are you seriously telling me, the
forum, and the rest of the world that your 'thing' is still over heating.
Didn't that new 'waterless' turbo do something or anything to alleviate the problem.
The only thing you NEED to do to cure your problem is piff that heap of garbage and buy a Toyota. (ROFLMAO)
And to think (acting on your advice) I just went to
Sydney looking for a the right Nissan to buy. Didn't see a Nissan on the road up there or anywhere for that matter.
Saw some nice JEEPS though and had an extremely interesting time wheeling one back to
Melbourne.
Must go, and AUSTRAVEL
check with member TREVOR ( comes from near the Qld/NSW border). He fixed his GU O/H problem.
Oh Roachie Ooops meant Blowfly (Mate it just never ends, ROF with tears in my eyes LMAO)
FollowupID:
397006
Follow Up By: Austravel - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:37
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 18:37
Thanks Lucy. Not a member so can't actually contact him. Do you know what his fix was??
FollowupID:
397007
Follow Up By: Member - Roachie (SA) - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:10
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:10
Thanks for those valued words of wisdom Mr Lucy....much appreciated... (NOT!!!! hahahahaha)
Austravel,...... Trevor has mentioned that he still has some issues with temp going up to what he considers unacceptable levels. He thought that his fix would work (he had the MTQ turbo upgrade done earlier this year), but alas he is still having some issues.
FollowupID:
397011
Follow Up By: Member - Trevor R (QLD) - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:11
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:11
Member Lucy,
It has only just started to happen again, but
mine is getting back to the bad old days of running hot again. Not as bad as it used to be but still too hot for me to suggest a complete and comprehensive fix has been achieved by my expensive cure (I say that term very loosely). As I have not investigated blocked radiator since my recent trip to
Roma I can't comment on whether there is a genuine reason for the vehicle to have started this nonsense again.
By the way I reside in BrisVegas but am hardly ever here due to work that allows me to travel the east coast like a yoyo. Someone has to do it ;-))).
Very best regards Trevor.
FollowupID:
397012
Follow Up By: Austravel - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:39
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 19:39
Thanks Trevor, Roachie,
So I'm not alone!! Hate to be the odd one out.
So does
mine sound similar to what your experiencing or worse???
That's my main concern if it sounds worse/farworse than what happens to you guys. If not then I guess I still need to try and sort it out but it's not urgent.
FollowupID:
397015
Follow Up By: Member - Trevor R (QLD) - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 21:48
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 21:48
Austravel,
Your situation sonds similar to what I experience, a careful eye on the factory Nissan gauge should keep you away from the Nissan garage for now. The factory Nissan gauge does not tell the whole story though. The VDO gauge moves quite a bit before the Nissan gauge moves in
mine, but when the Nissan gauge does move it is often too late just to take it easy, so for me the VDO gauge is critical in preventing the overheating from occurring in the first place. I am tending to think an EGT will even be more advantagous in determining when the vehicle is likely to climb the temp ladder, but Roachie or turbo specialist could inform you better on this.
Before the MTQ mods I had done, my running temps (I almost always tow) were around 100 - 110c. Now they are down to 95c but that has been through winter and just the other day on route to
Roma they were at about 100c without trailer and climb much higher on the big climbs. So I am now wondering with summer coming on again whether I have indented this problem at all?? couple more weeks will tell as I have another 5000km to do between now and 2nd week in January.
Last but not least, YOU ARE DEFINEATELY NOT ALONE, welcome to my world :-))) (in good humour).
Cheers and keep your eye on the gauge.
Trevor.
FollowupID:
397058
Follow Up By: Member - JohnR (Vic)&Moses - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 21:59
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 21:59
Austravel, Ray, seems like you and Roachie have something else in common - a big frontal area with the Nissan AND a trailer. Do you think it could be a problematic area? Notice Bill says his problem drops away as his speed drops to 95kph and quite a drop in fuel consumption too of course.
Bill, do you have an upgraded radiator as in the intercooled ones like
mine?
FollowupID:
397061
Follow Up By: Member - Trevor R (QLD) - Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 22:29
Monday, Dec 12, 2005 at 22:29
John,
The frontal area is something I have looked at closely, early on in the piece. Problem with that arguement is
mine used to (and may still) run hot with no spots on and no trailer, if I wanted it to (heavy right foot and half decent range is all it took on a hot day). I think there is many contributing factors in this saga but Roachie touched on the biggy in my opinion when he talked about the size of the water jackets.
Cheers Trevor.
FollowupID:
397068
Follow Up By: Nudenut - Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 07:47
Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 07:47
what happend to that electric pump you were going to fit?
also have you considered water injection? would this help in keeping
the block cool?
water cavitation ......how'd he know that was the cause...cavitaion is caused by the introduction of air at the impellor. caviation could be for various reasons but most likely due to a suction restriction or air leaking into the suction of the pump.........if we assume a suction restriction, it caviation would be caused by the existing impellor trying to pull a high vacuum causing the water to artifcially "boil"?
so generally if one was wanting to get more water flow a larger impellor would do the trick...but if the existing was cavitating a larger impellor would in most instances make for more cavitation, or cause cavitation to become a reality......I must admit though, a good designed impellor can prevent cavitation....But only within the limitations put upon the impellor.
FollowupID:
397115
Follow Up By: Austravel - Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 09:56
Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 09:56
Thanks everyone for your input. Looks like the solution is going to be "steady as she goes".
Had hoped to be able to push along in the NT if I got the chance next year but looks like that's not an option.
Will
check out the water temp gauge and quiz a turbo guy about the benifits of fitting an EGT in this particular case.
All the best.
FollowupID:
397131
Follow Up By: Member - Ross H (QLD) - Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 16:44
Tuesday, Dec 13, 2005 at 16:44
Hi guys
Dont know if this will help but here goes. Amate of
mine likes to put big motors into jags and they have a lot of over heating problems and one simple fix they have found is that hot air gets trapped at the top of the engine bay. most newer cars have 3/4 bonnet seals and what they do is lift the bonnet about 5 mill on the back edge and this allows the hot air to escape and clean air to flow over the motor. Maybe you could just remove the back seal and see what happens. Cheap fix if it work , just a thought
regards
ross
FollowupID:
397187