Saturday, Apr 08, 2017 at 13:53
I keep hearing this AGM comparison .... and AGM....AGM....AGM.
Serioulsy ....... there are very few situations that actually require AGM or where AGM has any specific advantage.
A lot of sellers will offer nothing but AGM .... simply because they do not have the ability to economically freight wet cell batteries .... AGM can be shipped in general freight.... wet cell batteries can not.
You can save yourself a lot of cost by rejecting the assumption that AGM is best ...... in many of the commercial high intesity applications AGM is not the prefered option and has no advantage.
Most golf buggies and small electric vehicles use conventional screw top wet cell batteries and in the market "Trojan" dominates.
Many remote area and off
grid installations use either screw top batteries or sealed maintenence free batteries. ..... because they will stand the hammering better than AGM.
Yes a lot of modern telecommunicaton installations particularly small ones are using AGM .... mostly because of workplace saftey and freight issues more than anything else.
You may wish to avoid the issues of maintenance and go for a sealed maintenance free battery, that will have most of the advantages of AGM but at 1/2 to 2/3 the cost ..... AND they will generally be more temperature tollerant than AGM and tolerate higher charge rates.
While you are at it look at AGM manufacturer spec sheets and the recommended operating temperature range is quite narrow.
If you have AGM because it does not require ventilation ...... think again ..... ALL responsible AGM battery sellers and ALL manufacturers clearly state thet AGM batteries require ventilation.
There are a lot of AGM batteries out there living very short lives, because of failure to control charge rate and being used outside their recommended temperature range ..... this could have been avoided using a similar spec sealed maintenence free wet cell battery battery rather than a starved electrolite battery (what we used to call them before marketing made up the AGM label)
Because the AGM battery is starved of electrolite they can not cool them selves as efficiently..... thus the charge rate and temperature range is often limited.
Yes there are high charge and discharge rated AGM batteries out there with good temperature tolerance ...... but they are far more expensive than those commonly sold.
Please consider other options ....... there are good options other than AGM and at considerably less cost.
cheers
FollowupID:
879948